Poole MP Neil Duncan-Jordan wrote to the Work and Pensions Secretary over PIP for young disabled people. The letter sets four tests for the Milburn Review.

Poole MP Neil Duncan-Jordan has asked the Government not to take Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit away from young disabled people, in a letter sent to Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden on 12 November ahead of the Milburn Review.

The Labour MP wrote after media reports that day suggested the review would recommend withdrawing both payments from young people. In his letter he says:

“Young disabled people will not cease to be disabled if the support they rely on is cut; they will simply be poorer.”

Mr Duncan-Jordan was suspended from the Parliamentary Labour Party for his part in last year’s welfare rebellion, his office said in its release.

What the letter says

The letter, which Mr Duncan-Jordan posted on X and which can be read in full here, makes three main points.

Most people on the health element are already deprived. “Some 75% of people receiving the health element of Universal Credit already experience deprivation and withdrawing this support from young people risks making an already desperate situation even worse,” he writes.

PIP is not an out-of-work benefit. He says PIP “helps meet the additional costs of living with a disability, providing support that allows people to work and live independently.” He goes on:

“Removing support that helps people overcome barriers to employment would therefore directly contradict the Government’s stated objective of supporting more people into work.”

A new higher benefit for the most disabled is not reassuring. The letter questions the reported claim that “those with the most profound disabilities who are not capable of working would be given a new benefit, paid at a higher rate.” Mr Duncan-Jordan points out that UC and PIP already pay different rates depending on how severely a disability affects someone, and says similar wording was used by the previous Government last year, when its proposed PIP cuts “were later revealed to be targeting people with severe disabilities, such as those who were unable to go to the toilet unassisted. We cannot repeat this approach.”

He also cites the interim report of the separate Timms Review, which he says “has highlighted that existing support is insufficient to provide a decent standard of living.” The letter notes that the Milburn Review was commissioned under the previous Government.

His four tests for the review

The letter sets out four questions the MP wants answered before the Government settles its response:

  1. Will the proposals make disabled people poorer?
  2. What employment support will be available, how much will be invested, how long will it last, and will opportunities be tailored to an individual’s skills and circumstances?
  3. How will the proposals define severe disabilities, and what impact will they have on people with severe or fluctuating conditions?
  4. Will any conditions cease to qualify for support altogether and how will this assessment be made?

He has asked to meet the Secretary of State, alongside Disabled People’s Organisations, before the Government decides its formal position on both the Milburn and Timms Reviews.

“A springboard, not a trapdoor”

The letter welcomes what it calls the Prime Minister’s “refreshed approach” to health and welfare, including his opposition to “crude cuts” and his aim of bringing down the welfare bill by tackling ill health, low wages, the lack of affordable housing and the high cost of living.

But Mr Duncan-Jordan says Labour must learn from last year’s attempted cuts and from the austerity years:

“Benefit cuts and sanctions do not create jobs, but increase poverty and place greater pressure on the NHS, local councils and other public services, ultimately costing us more in the long run. Our welfare state should be a springboard, not a trapdoor into poverty which enables those who can, to get into work, and ensures nobody in our country goes without the essentials they need to live.”

His office says he also recently organised a joint letter from Labour MPs about upcoming changes to disability benefits.

What it means for you

  • Nothing has changed yet. The Milburn Review has not been published, and the Government has not given its response. The proposals in the letter are ones reported in the media, not decisions.
  • Who is affected if they go ahead: young people who receive PIP or the health element of Universal Credit. No age limit or start date has been published.
  • Poole constituents who want to raise their own case with Mr Duncan-Jordan can call his office on 01202 160740, email neil.duncanjordan.mp@parliament.uk, or go through neilforpoole.co.uk.