The Save SOBO Beach campaign says its FOI requests have been held up and is now examining BCP's 19 financial rule breaches, worth £48.3m in 2025/26.
The Save SOBO Beach campaign says Freedom of Information requests it sent BCP Council on 13 October have had their deadlines extended while the council considers withholding material as commercially sensitive, and it is now turning its attention to the council’s wider finances. The campaign, which opposes the council’s choice of a new operator for a 20-year concession on Southbourne Promenade, issued a statement on Thursday, a day after SOBO Beach’s operator started a legal challenge that has suspended the contract.
The campaign says the council has given assurances of a “fair and legal process” but has not shown the evidence. “A Council cannot simply declare that it has followed the correct process and expect residents to take its word for it,” said Dan Astin-Gregory, the campaign’s co-founder. “Good governance should be demonstrable.”
The information requests
The campaign says it has asked the council more than 20 questions about community consultation, financial checks on the bidders, safeguards against conflicts of interest and how decisions were made, and that many have had no response. Its formal requests under the Freedom of Information Act have been given extended deadlines while the council weighs the exemption in section 43(2), which covers information whose release would be likely to harm someone’s commercial interests.
The campaign accepts that some material may need protecting, and says it has not established that the extensions are unlawful. Its complaint is that confidentiality is being applied too widely.
“Commercial confidentiality cannot become a blanket answer to every uncomfortable question,” Mr Astin-Gregory said. “We are not asking for competitors’ confidential business plans to be published.
“We are asking for evidence that the Council complied with its own procedures, undertook the required checks and properly informed elected representatives.
“Take something as straightforward as whether meaningful public consultation was undertaken before designing the tender. Why should it be so difficult to obtain a clear, documented answer to that question?”
The council’s revised Seafront Strategy, which went to Cabinet in July 2024, says that “individual projects will be subject to further engagement exercises as they come forward”. The campaign says the council has yet to show how that was done for Southbourne.
What the council’s own reports say
The campaign now plans to look beyond the beach, using the council’s published finance and audit papers. It points to two.
The first is the forecast overspend. BCP’s quarter two budget monitoring puts the 2026/27 general fund overspend at £31.7 million, £4.7 million more than the quarter before; we reported the figures on 7 November.
The second is the annual report on breaches of the council’s Financial Regulations, which went to the Audit and Governance Committee on 30 July. We read it. It records 19 breaches in 2025/26 on contracts totalling £48,264,240, up from 12 breaches worth £29.2 million in 2024/25 and 7 worth £15.4 million in 2023/24. A breach here means money was committed without the procurement approval the rules require.
Two cases make up almost all of the 2025/26 total:
- £30,188,170 on 110 new homes. The procurement team approved the pre-construction phase but was not involved in the construction contract, and no approval was sought for it. The report says officers wrongly assumed none was needed because Cabinet and Council had approved the work.
- £15,725,710 on emergency B&B and hotel rooms for homeless households. An internal audit found that approval had never been considered for this spending, a practice the report says was carried over from the councils that merged to form BCP. A 15-month approval is now in place.
The report says the “relatively low number of breaches suggests a good level of understanding” of the rules among managers, that the main cause was a lack of awareness, and that training and new procedures have followed.
Mr Astin-Gregory reads it differently. “When you start examining the Council’s own financial and governance reports, the questions become considerably bigger,” he said. “We are looking at substantial financial pressures, documented breaches of financial regulations and acknowledged governance weaknesses.
“It raises serious questions about the current administration’s ability to deliver the standards of governance and accountability that residents are entitled to expect.”
What happens next
The operator’s challenge means the 20-year contract cannot be signed while the suspension lasts. The campaign is separately pursuing scrutiny through the council’s Audit and Governance referral, which the committee takes up at an extra meeting on 26 November, and is talking to independent solicitors about a judicial review of its own on issues outside the procurement. It has not started proceedings. The next Full Council is on 8 December.
“Our concern is not that every difficult decision must go the way residents want,” Mr Astin-Gregory said. “It is that decisions affecting public money, public assets and local communities must be properly informed, transparent and accountable.
“SOBO Beach may have brought these questions to light, but they do not begin and end with SOBO Beach.”
The campaign says it has more than 10,800 petition signatures and over 6,000 supporter messages. BCP Council had not published a response to the campaign’s statement when we checked on 12 November; we will add it when it does.
Earlier reports: the legal challenge, the standstill ending and the 13 October vote.
Have your say